UNFPA has studied the consequences of resource
shortfalls, based on three scenarios in which resources fail to meet Cairo targets:
- the Constant Growth Scenario assumes that developing countries
meet the Cairo targets while donor resources continue their current below-target rate of
growth;
- the Intermediate Growth Scenario assumes that international
assistance will grow 20 per cent slower than in the first scenario; and
- the Low Growth Scenario assumes that developing countries fall
short of the target while donors continue their current rate of growth.
The most optimistic or "constant growth" scenario still registers a $2.1
billion deficit in resources by the year 2000 compared to ICPD targets. Table 1 summarizes
these three scenarios.
By the year 2000 there will be 1.35 billion women between 15 and 45. Of these, 950
million are expected to be married or in steady relationships. By 2000, if reproductive
health and family planning information and services are provided in line with the ICPD
goals, 610-640 million of these couples would be using some form of contraception.
More Potential Family
Planning Users
Without Contraception
Assuming the least grave of UNFPAs three scenarios, the smallest shortfall in
resources, 97 million additional individuals and couples who would have chosen
contraception will not be able to do so. Under the Intermediate Growth Scenario the figure
is 130 million and with the Low Growth Scenario 170 million.
Under the first of the three scenarios, the number of couples having access to and
using reproductive health and family planning services would be 16 per cent lower than if
Cairo resource goals are not met. The Intermediate Growth Scenario would mean a shortfall
of 21 per cent, and the worst case 30 per cent. One effect will be that more people will
use less effective traditional contraceptive methods: others will use no method at all.
More Unwanted Pregnancies
With inadequate contraceptive coverage, the number of unintended pregnancies will
riseby 130 million for the period 1995-2000 under the least grave scenario, climbing
to 230 million under the worst case.
For the women concerned, unintended pregnancies can have serious life and health
consequences; at the least they mean additional costs in lost work time and perinatal
care. For their countries, the consequences of unintended births are additional
investments in health, education, housing and employmentor perhaps just more
additions to the ranks of the poor and hopeless.
More Abortions
Many of these unintended pregnancies will not come to term. If resources fall short,
the number of abortions will increase dramaticallyfrom 50 million extra abortions to
more than 90 million over the period 1995-2000, depending on the resource scenario.
Besides the negative health and other effects on millions of women, the costs to
overburdened health systems from unsafe abortions will escalate. Complications from unsafe
abortions are among the leading causes of hospitalization for women of reproductive age in
developing countries.
More Unwanted Births
Depending on the resources scenario, there are likely to be somewhere between 60
million and 110 million additional unwanted births between 1995 and 2000.
These extra births imply significant burdens in terms of health risks to the mother at
time of delivery, additional demands on health care services, and a general erosion of
resources available to poor families.
More Deaths and Injuries
Resulting from Pregnancy
Depending on the resources scenario, there will be between 300,000 and 540,000 total
extra maternal deaths between 1995 and 2000, that is, between 100,000 to 180,000 annually
by the year 2000. Lack of resources would also make it more difficult to improve emergency
obstetric care, antenatal care and the proportion of births attended by a trained health
professional.
Maternal morbidity will increase dramatically. Shortfalls in resources could result in
3.8 million to 7 million additional cases of life-threatening complications and illnesses
related to unwanted pregnancies. In the year 2000 alone, the number of women affected
would range from 1.3 million to 2.3 million.
Increased Infant and Child
Mortality
Currently, around 125 million children are born in developing countries every year.
More than 7.5 million die before reaching their first birthday, and another 3.2 million
before reaching five years of age. If Cairo resource targets are not met, these rates will
rise sharply, depending on the resources scenario. Between 1995 and 2000, even under the
most optimistic of the three scenarios, an additional 3.6 million infants and 1.3 million
children will die.
Under the Intermediate Growth Scenario, the combined number of infant and child deaths
rises to 6.4 million and to almost 9 million with the Low Growth Scenario. These
additional infant and child deaths will be a direct consequence of the enormous increase
in unintended pregnancies noted earlier.
Effects of Shortfalls
on Services and Infrastructure
Limited resources will hold back efforts to improve the quality and coverage of
reproductive health servicesthe range of contraceptive methods available, the
technical competence of staff, and the quality of information and communication
programmes, for example.
Current resource shortfalls have already harmed service delivery. In Tanzania, for
instance, three-quarters of all health centres and hospitals surveyed did not have a
speculum, nearly one-third lacked disposable gloves and 22 per cent and 15 per cent,
respectively, did not even have a stethoscope.
The broader effects are even more ominous. In Nicaragua, one of the poorest countries
in Latin America, population is growing by 3 per cent a year, with mounting debt and an
increasing number of rural and urban poor. Nicaragua must find the resources to train an
extra 3,000 teachers over the next five years and build facilities to accommodate another
30,000 students. By 2040, unless population growth is slowed considerably, the country
will need to educate an additional 9,000 doctors, 20,000 nurses and build 2,000 new health
posts. By contrast, the cost of guaranteeing every citizen access to appropriate family
planning services has been estimated at no more than $20 per person per year. |